[cdwg] Wiki Update

Christopher J. Morrone morrone2 at llnl.gov
Wed Nov 7 13:27:13 PST 2012


On 11/07/2012 01:08 PM, John Carrier wrote:
> Chris,
>
> When Shay first had the mediawiki set up, there were a couple problems I encountered.  Anyone could register on the wiki regardless of affiliation and anyone registered could add/remove content.  We need to allow the wiki to be moderated before updates get posted.  There were also issues with uploading files (ie they weren't enabled).

First, those issues are just configuration details, not fundamental 
problems with either Mediawiki or our service level at Dreamhost.  Now 
more detail:

Permissions: Is that REALLY necessary?  Our opensfs wiki is nearly 
entirely unused.  You talked about the TWG area on the wiki on a recent 
call.  But that area is just an empty stub, not an actually used area. 
Why is that?

To make the wiki better, I think Nathan and I are of the opinion that we 
need to lower the bar for contribution.

But like I said, Mediawiki is configurable.  The main modes are 
something like:

   A) Anyone can create/modify pages without an account.  Anyone can
      view pages.
   B) Anyone who creates an account can create/modify pages.  Anyone can
      view pages.
   C) Anyone who creates an account, and then someone else authorizes
      that account can create/modify pages.  Anyone can view pages.
   D) Private wiki.  Only those with accounts and authorization can even
      view the wiki.

I selected "B" the first time through configuring it.  That will stop 
the dumber bots from spaming our wiki.  I think it would be reasonable 
to wait until people actually start causing problems, or we get bots 
that are auto-creating accounts on our site and spamming us (although we 
might also look into captcha to help avoid bots).

But if people are really paranoid, I suppose C would work, and I would 
just try to authorize all new accounts from recognized names and/or 
organizations as soon as possible.

Uploads:  I turned them on.  Max file size increased to 64MB.  That can 
be changed if needed.

Chris




More information about the cdwg mailing list